: While some compare its energy to "NC-17," others feel it lacks the unique edge found in other leaked Utopia era tracks like "Lost Forever". Summary Verdict
The track is characterized by a sleek, spacey atmosphere that many fans feel would have fit perfectly on Astroworld .
: Conversely, others view it as one of his best leaks since 2018, praising the concise rapping and "beautiful" production that doesn't rely solely on beat switches to be interesting.
: Some fans argue the song is "mid" because it stays in Travis’s established "safe lane" of mainstream pop-trap rather than pushing the experimental boundaries seen on Utopia .
"Heartbeat" is a polarizing "grail" among Travis Scott fans that leaked during the lead-up to Utopia . While it ultimately didn't make the final album cut, it remains a staple in the unreleased community for its smooth, melodic energy.