Readers and reviewers from Lemon8 and Goodreads highlight the book's enchanting holiday spirit and detailed character development, specifically noting:
The story follows Kat Claus, who finds herself alone on Christmas Eve after a fight with her husband, Nic. During this lonely night, she reconnects with her neighbor, Noelle. As the two share confessions and an unexpected kiss, their relationship is forever altered. Stealing Mrs. Claus by Pru Schuyler
: The inclusion of a playlist is noted for heightening the emotional engagement of the story. Readers and reviewers from Lemon8 and Goodreads highlight
: Reviewers found the journey of characters like Nic to be relatable and layered. Nic. During this lonely night
: The evolving bond between Kat and Noelle is described as sweet and refreshing for the festive season.