Reviewers at BeFreed note that Mack’s personal hockey background adds credibility to the on-ice scenes.

Unlike many light sports romances, this book tackles heavy themes such as infertility , grief from family loss, and recovery from past trauma.

Some readers on The StoryGraph and Goodreads feel the book is unnecessarily long (over 500 pages) and that the therapeutic dialogue can occasionally feel unrealistic for professional athletes. Play With Me (Playing for Keeps, #2) by Becka Mack

Critics and readers generally praise the book for its authentic hockey knowledge and relatable characters, though its length is a common point of discussion.

Garrett is frequently described by readers on platforms like Instagram as the ultimate "green flag" boyfriend—supportive, patient, and devoted. Reader Reviews & Reception

by Becka Mack is the second book in the Playing for Keeps series, a popular hockey romance known for its blend of spicy chemistry and deep emotional exploration. Book Overview & Tropes

It is rated high for heat (often 4/5 or "explicit open door"), featuring several notable steamy scenes, including an early encounter involving Jennie’s collection of adult toys.

The story follows , a star right winger for the Vancouver Vipers, and Jennie Beckett , a professional dancer and the younger sister of the team's captain.