While popular with some, the idea was also met with debate regarding the character’s dual nature:

Many fans have long campaigned for to be cast as She-Hulk (Jennifer Walters) in the Marvel Cinematic Universe . While Tatiana Maslany eventually took the role for the Disney+ series, fan interest in Carano as the "Savage She-Hulk" remains a popular topic of discussion and creative fan art. Why Fans Wanted Gina Carano as She-Hulk

Supporters often cite Carano’s background as an MMA pioneer and her physical presence as the primary reasons she would have been a great fit for the character:

: Some critics argued that while Carano looked the part of the "Hulked-out" version, she might not have been the best choice to play Jennifer Walters, the mild-mannered lawyer.

: Numerous digital artists have created mock-ups showing Carano in the iconic green skin and purple-and-white suit. The Casting Debate

Gina Carano is no longer affiliated with Disney or Lucasfilm following her departure from The Mandalorian in 2021. She recently shared that she has moved to Montana and married her longtime partner, Kevin Ross. Could She-Hulk be recast in the MCU? - Facebook

: A popular fan theory suggested casting two different women—one for Jen Walters and a physically imposing actress like Carano or Gwendoline Christie for the She-Hulk form, similar to how the 1970s Incredible Hulk show used Bill Bixby and Lou Ferrigno. Current Status